Senator James McGrath – opposing Senator McKim’s motion calling for a permanent ceasefire

photo of Senator James McGrath
December 4, 2023

The ceasefire ended because Hamas broke the terms of the ceasefire by failing to release the list of names of hostages, and then started bombing, again, innocent Israeli citizens. The only way to end this war is for Hamas, who are a terrorist organisation, to release the hostages.

Senator McGRATH (Queensland) (16:33): I am going to read out this matter of public urgency that has been lodged by the Greens:

Given the end of the truce in Gaza and the intensification of the state of Israel’s bombing in Southern Gaza, the Australian Government must call for an immediate permanent ceasefire to end the humanitarian catastrophe occurring in Gaza, for the unconditional release of all hostages and political prisoners and for an urgent end to the siege and invasion of Gaza.

This is where the Greens are at their absolute worst. The ceasefire came about because Israel sat down and tried to do a deal with Hamas for the release of hostages, over 240 hostages who were kidnapped by Hamas on 7 October, a date that will live in infamy for the State of Israel and for all of those who believe in free Liberal democracies, when terrorists pushed through the border and invaded Israel, a free country, and murdered over 1,200 free people living in Israel. Not only was there murder and assaults; we saw sexualised violence being used against Israelis, where people were sexually assaulted and then murdered, where people were raped and then murdered. But you don’t hear the Greens talking about the sexualised violence that was used against Israeli citizens.

The ceasefire ended because Hamas broke the terms of the ceasefire by failing to release the list of names of hostages, and then started bombing, again, innocent Israeli citizens. The only way to end this war is for Hamas, who are a terrorist organisation, to release the hostages. The release of some hostages is just a tiny reminder of the torture that Hamas has inflicted on hundreds of families, on millions of Israelis, on hundreds of millions of people around this world who believe in freedom and liberty and who are suffering because of the actions of a terrorist organisation.

It is so sad that, in Australia, we have supporters of Hamas, like those people who invaded the hotel in Melbourne last week, targeting the families of hostages—families who were in this building last week, families who were out the front of this Australian Parliament House, families who met with members and senators to talk about their stories such as the mum whose son was murdered. These Hamas supporters in Australia think it is perfectly acceptable to invade a hotel and attack people through that invasion.

We use this word ‘antisemitism’, and I’m going to call it out for what it is. Antisemitism does not get down to the nuts and bolts of what is ascribed to antisemitism. If you are antisemitic, you are anti-Jew, and we’ve got to call that out. The actions of those protesters in Melbourne last week were anti-Jewish. The actions of Hamas are anti-Jewish. But we shouldn’t be surprised that the Greens are like this. We should not forget that Senator Faruqi, the Deputy Leader of the Greens in this chamber, put on Instagram a photo of her standing beside someone holding a sign saying, ‘Keep the world clean of Jews’. This is the Greens for you—a party who thinks it’s acceptable to put signs like that on social media. Shame on the Greens!

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT ( Senator Walsh ): Resume your seat, Senator McGrath. Senator Waters?

Senator Waters: Senator Faruqi took down that photograph and apologised for it being posted. I think the record needs to accurately reflect what occurred.

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: I think that has been noted previously in the chamber.

Senator McGRATH: Senator Faruqi put a sign up on her Instagram saying, ‘Clean the world of Jews’. Shame on the Greens! Shame on Senator Faruqi!

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senator McCarthy.

Senator McGrath interjecting

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Resume your seat, Senator McCarthy. Senator Steele-John?

Senator Steele-John: Senator McGrath just uttered the most disgusting accusation of me and my colleagues in relation to antisemitism. I won’t—I can’t—repeat what he just said. He must withdraw. I have never heard anything like that in my life.

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senator Steele-John, I was just getting ready to move the call and—Senator McGrath?

Senator McGrath: I withdraw.

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senator McCarthy.

Senator McGrath interjecting

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: No! No! No! No!

Senator McGrath interjecting

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Senator McGrath, leave the chamber in silence.

Senator McGrath interjecting

The ACTING DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Leave the chamber in silence.

Link to Parliamentary Hansard